Best Areas to Buy in St Maarten:
Simpson Bay, Cupecoy, Oyster Pond and Terres Basses

Best Areas to Buy in St Maarten: Simpson Bay, Cupecoy, Oyster Pond and Terres Basses
The best areas to buy in St Maarten, the Dutch side of the island, are Simpson Bay, Pelican Key and Maho for rentals, Cupecoy for modern condos, and the quieter east around Oyster Pond and Guana Bay, where one brokerage quotes villas from about US$1 million to US$2 million. Terres Basses is on the French side. Dutch-side purchases carry a 4% buyer transfer tax, as at October 2026.
Key takeaways
Buying costs: Dutch-side St Maarten purchases run through a civil law notary with a 4% buyer transfer tax.
Dutch-side villas: Dutch-side villas in areas such as Guana Bay or Oyster Pond are estimated to cost from about US$1-2 million for a solid three or four-bedroom home.
Terres Basses prices: Terres Basses villas are estimated to generally start at US$2 million.
St Maarten (officially Sint Maarten) is the Dutch half of an island shared with French Saint-Martin and, since 10 October 2010, an autonomous constituent country of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, with its own parliament, prime minister and courts. Foreign policy and defence are Kingdom matters. Residents hold Dutch nationality, but the island is outside the European Union and the Schengen Area. The currency is the Caribbean guilder, which replaced the Netherlands Antillean guilder on 31 March 2025 at 1.79 to the US dollar.
St Maarten is one island with two legal systems, and where you buy decides which one applies. The areas below group into the busy west, the quiet east and the French side.
Key facts
Legal framework: St Maarten (officially Sint Maarten) is the Dutch half of an island shared with French Saint-Martin and, since 10 October 2010, an autonomous constituent country of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, with its own parliament, prime minister and courts. Foreign policy and defence are Kingdom matters. Residents hold Dutch nationality, but the island is outside the European Union and the Schengen Area. The currency is the Caribbean guilder, which replaced the Netherlands Antillean guilder on 31 March 2025 at 1.79 to the US dollar. (Verified)
Dutch-side purchases run through a civil law notary with a 4% buyer transfer tax; French-side purchases follow French law (Verified)
Area character: Simpson Bay and Pelican Key (marinas, restaurants, nightlife, strong rental activity), Maho (beach, casinos, tourist turnover), Cupecoy (modern condos, near the American University of the Caribbean and Porto Cupecoy marina), Beacon Hill (condos), Dawn Beach, Oyster Pond and Guana Bay (quieter, east side; Oyster Pond straddles the Dutch-French border and suits boaters), and on the French side Terres Basses (large gated villa parcels), Orient Bay (beach community) and Grand Case (quieter, waterfront restaurants) (Corroborated)
Dutch-side villas in areas such as Guana Bay or Oyster Pond cost from about US$1-2 million for a solid three or four-bedroom home; Terres Basses villas generally start at US$2 million and the finest beachfront estates reach US$5 million and above (Estimate)
Simpson Bay, Beacon Hill and Cupecoy have the largest number of condo listings on the Dutch side; Simpson Bay and Maho rank as the highest-occupancy vacation rental zones (Estimate)
Simpson Bay, Pelican Key and Maho
On the Dutch side, Simpson Bay and Pelican Key are the convenience and rental heartland, close to marinas, restaurants, nightlife and shops. Agencies describe Simpson Bay and Maho as the highest-occupancy vacation rental zones on the island, which is consistent with the rental data in our St Maarten's Property Market: Where Prices and Rentals Stand guide, though the claim comes from agency guides. Maho adds the airport beach, casinos and heavy tourist turnover, so it suits investors more than anyone wanting quiet. Condos and waterfront residences dominate.
Cupecoy and Beacon Hill
Cupecoy is the modern end of the market, with newer condo buildings, Mullet Bay Beach nearby, and proximity to the American University of the Caribbean and Porto Cupecoy marina, which supports steady demand from students and seasonal residents. Brokers say Simpson Bay, Beacon Hill and Cupecoy have the largest number of condo listings on the Dutch side. The Cupecoy corridor is also where several new residential projects are marketed, covered in our What's New in St Maarten: The Airport Terminal, The Morgan and Sonesta's Rooftop guide.
The east: Dawn Beach, Oyster Pond and Guana Bay
For a quieter setting, the eastern side offers ocean views and separation from the busiest districts. Oyster Pond sits on the Dutch-French border around a lagoon and suits boaters, and Dawn Beach and Guana Bay have villas and ocean-view apartments. One brokerage puts solid three or four-bedroom villas in Guana Bay or Oyster Pond from about US$1 million to US$2 million.
The French side
On the French side, Terres Basses is the prestige address, with large gated parcels and villas. The same brokerage says villas there generally start at US$2 million, and the finest beachfront estates reach US$5 million and above. Orient Bay is a beach community with steady visitor demand, and Grand Case suits buyers who want a quieter base near some of the island's best-known waterfront restaurants.
What changes with the side
A Dutch-side purchase runs through a civil law notary and carries a 4% buyer transfer tax, covered in our legal and tax guide to St Maarten. A French-side purchase follows French law, with its own notary process, and its costs were not researched for this article, so get them from a French-side notary before comparing the two. The lifestyle article explains how the two sides differ in daily life.
Choosing between them
Simpson Bay and Maho suit rental income. Cupecoy suits modern condos. The east suits quiet and boating. Terres Basses suits ultra-prime villa buyers. Whatever the area, ask for sold comparables, check the condition and insurance of any building, and remember that the island has taken a direct hurricane hit, as our What Buying and Living in St Maarten Actually Costs guide explains.
Questions and answers
Where is the best place to buy a rental property in St Maarten?
Agencies describe Simpson Bay and Maho as the highest-occupancy vacation rental zones on the island, though the claim comes from agency guides. Simpson Bay and Pelican Key are close to marinas, restaurants, nightlife and shops.
How much does a villa cost in St Maarten?
One brokerage puts solid three or four-bedroom villas in Guana Bay or Oyster Pond from about US$1 million to US$2 million. On the French side, the same brokerage says Terres Basses villas generally start at US$2 million, and the finest beachfront estates reach US$5 million and above.
What is the transfer tax when buying on the Dutch side of St Maarten?
A Dutch-side purchase runs through a civil law notary and carries a 4% buyer transfer tax. A French-side purchase follows French law, with its own notary process.
Where are the quietest areas to buy in St Maarten?
The eastern side, including Dawn Beach, Oyster Pond and Guana Bay, offers ocean views and separation from the busiest districts. Oyster Pond sits on the Dutch-French border around a lagoon and suits boaters.
Related guides
More on St Maarten
St Maarten's Property Market: Where Prices and Rentals Stand
What's New in St Maarten: The Airport Terminal, The Morgan and Sonesta's Rooftop
Similar guides for other islands
Best Areas to Buy in the BVI: Tortola, Virgin Gorda and the Smaller Islands
St Thomas, St John or St Croix: Comparing the USVI's Property Markets
Best Areas to Buy in Guadeloupe: Saint-François, Le Gosier, Deshaies and the Outer Islands
About the data
Figures are the latest available as of October 2026. Next review due April 2027.
This guide draws on 7 sources: 7 agency, adviser or other published source.
2 figure(s) are marked Estimate.
Prices quoted are asking prices or estimates unless stated, and may differ from achieved prices.
Fact statuses: Verified means stated by a primary or official source (Verified (see note) adds a caveat). Corroborated means several independent sources agree, but no primary source was found. Estimate means a single source, an agency figure or an asking price. Disputed means sources conflict. Calculated by Pan Caribbean means our own arithmetic from the figures shown.
Sources and checks
Researched October 2026. Next review due April 2027.
7th Heaven Properties: St Maarten and St Martin real estate (agency, adviser or other published source)
Real Estate SXM: where to invest in St Maarten (agency, adviser or other published source)
St Maarten Investments: guide to Saint Martin neighbourhoods (agency, adviser or other published source)
SMI SXM: best St Maarten villa communities (agency, adviser or other published source)
IDR: best areas to buy real estate in Sint Maarten (agency, adviser or other published source)
IDR: best neighbourhoods in Sint Maarten to buy property (agency, adviser or other published source)
Andreu Realty: top neighbourhoods in St Maarten and Saint Martin (agency, adviser or other published source)
About Pan Caribbean
Pan Caribbean is a property listing portal and market data platform covering 23 markets across the Caribbean. Buyers, investors, agents and developers can search, compare and research property throughout the region, all in one place.
This guide gives general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Pan Caribbean is not an estate agent or broker and does not act in any sale or purchase. Confirm the details with a licensed local adviser before acting.
Explore related blogs
View All
Best Areas to Buy in Dominica: Roseau, Portsmouth, the South, the West Coast and the North
Where to Buy: Area Guides

Best Areas to Buy in Martinique: Les Trois-Îlets, Sainte-Anne, Le Diamant and the Atlantic Coast
Where to Buy: Area Guides

Best Areas to Buy in Guadeloupe: Saint-François, Le Gosier, Deshaies and the Outer Islands
Where to Buy: Area Guides

Best Areas to Buy in St Vincent and the Grenadines: Villa, Bequia, Union Island and Beyond
Where to Buy: Area Guides
Looking for Properties?
Browse homes that match your needs and budget with expert support and personalized advice to help you find your perfect Caribbean property. Get started within 5 days for quality advice to begin searching.
